Which Scary Movie Has My Strong Hand?

Scary movies have been a favorite among horror enthusiasts for decades. From classic slashers to supernatural thrillers, there is no shortage of heart-pumping, nail-biting films to choose from. However, one movie that has gained a cult following for its bizarre and hilarious scenes is “Scary Movie 2” and the infamous scene of Brenda’s iconic line, “Which hand is it?”

In this article, we will explore the origins of this quote and why it has become such a memorable part of the horror comedy genre.

The Plot

“Scary Movie 2” follows a group of college students who are invited to spend the weekend at a haunted mansion. As they explore their surroundings, they encounter various supernatural occurrences and must navigate through them to survive.

One of the most unforgettable scenes in the film involves Brenda Meeks (played by Regina Hall) being possessed by a demonic force. As she begins to act erratically, she repeatedly asks her friends, “Which hand is it?” while holding out her arms.

The Inspiration

The line “Which hand is it?” was actually inspired by an episode of “The Twilight Zone” titled “The Hitch-Hiker.”

In this episode, a woman driving cross-country keeps seeing the same hitchhiker on her journey. No matter how far she travels or how fast she drives, he always manages to appear before her.

At one point in the episode, the hitchhiker asks the woman for a ride and holds out his hand. She notices that his left hand is missing and becomes frightened.

The Legacy

Despite its origins in “The Twilight Zone,” the line “Which hand is it?” has become synonymous with “Scary Movie 2.” Its absurdity and comedic timing have made it one of the most memorable quotes in horror comedy history.

It’s not just Brenda’s delivery that makes this scene so memorable. The use of lighting, camera angles, and music all contribute to the overall eerie atmosphere. The audience is left feeling uneasy and unsure of what will happen next.


“Scary Movie 2” may not be the scariest film in the horror genre, but it has certainly left its mark on pop culture. The iconic line “Which hand is it?” has become a staple in horror comedy and is sure to be remembered for years to come.

So, next time you watch “Scary Movie 2,” pay attention to Brenda’s infamous line and remember its origins in “The Twilight Zone.” And if you ever find yourself in a situation where someone asks you which hand it is, just remember: it’s always best to proceed with caution.