There has been a lot of debate among Star Trek fans about whether the 2009 movie is the first film in the franchise. Let’s dive into this topic and explore the various arguments for and against this claim.
What is Star Trek 2009?
Star Trek 2009 is a science-fiction movie directed by J.J. Abrams. It features an all-new cast playing iconic characters from the original Star Trek series, including James T. Kirk, Spock, and Leonard McCoy. The movie follows the crew of the USS Enterprise as they battle an evil Romulan named Nero who threatens to destroy Earth.
The Argument for Star Trek 2009 as the First Movie
One argument for Star Trek 2009 being considered as the first movie in the franchise is that it serves as a reboot of sorts, introducing new actors to play familiar characters and resetting the timeline of events. This argument suggests that since it essentially starts over with new actors and a new timeline, it can be considered a fresh start for the franchise.
The timeline reset in Star Trek 2009 occurs due to an event involving time travel. This event creates an alternate reality where events unfold differently than in the original series. Some fans argue that this means Star Trek 2009 is not just a reboot but also a prequel to all other movies in the franchise.
The Argument Against Star Trek 2009 as the First Movie
There are also arguments against considering Star Trek 2009 as the first movie in the franchise. One such argument stems from its continuity with previous films.
Continuity with Previous Films
While some may argue that Star Trek 2009 serves as a reboot, it still maintains continuity with previous films by featuring Leonard Nimoy reprising his role as Spock from earlier movies. Additionally, the movie references events and characters from earlier films, such as the appearance of the USS Kelvin from Star Trek: The Motion Picture.
The Motion Picture
Finally, some fans argue that Star Trek: The Motion Picture should be considered the first movie in the franchise. Released in 1979, it was the first film to feature the original cast reuniting after the series ended. It also set the tone for future movies by featuring grandiose special effects and a more cinematic approach to storytelling.
In conclusion, while there are arguments for and against considering Star Trek 2009 as the first movie in the franchise, it ultimately comes down to personal interpretation. Whether you see it as a reboot or a continuation of previous films, one thing is clear – Star Trek has had a long and successful run on both television and film.