How Scary Is the Movie Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark?

If you’re a horror movie enthusiast, chances are you’ve heard about the latest addition to the genre – Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark. The movie, released in 2019, is based on the book series of the same name by Alvin Schwartz. It’s directed by André Øvredal and produced by Guillermo del Toro.

The Premise

Set in 1968, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark follows a group of teenagers who stumble upon a haunted book that unleashes terrifying creatures into their small town of Mill Valley. The book belonged to Sarah Bellows, a young girl who was kept hidden away from the world due to her disfigured appearance. She wrote scary stories as a way of coping with her loneliness and anger.

The Monsters

One of the most notable aspects of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark are its monsters. These creatures are brought to life through impressive practical effects and CGI. From a pale lady with long hair that oozes black goo to a scarecrow that comes alive, each monster is unique and memorable.

The Jangly Man

Perhaps one of the scariest monsters in the movie is The Jangly Man. He’s made up of various body parts that are held together by his spine and can disassemble and reassemble himself at will. His movements are jerky and unnatural, making him an unsettling creature to watch on screen.

The Tone

While Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark is marketed as a horror movie for teenagers, it definitely has some moments that will make even seasoned horror fans jump in their seats. However, it also has moments of humor and heart that balance out the scares.

The Verdict

So how scary is Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark? It depends on your tolerance for horror movies.

If you’re someone who scares easily, this movie will definitely have you jumping and covering your eyes at times. However, the scares are balanced out with moments of humor and heart, making it a well-rounded horror movie that’s worth checking out.

  • Pros: Impressive practical effects and CGI, unique and memorable monsters
  • Cons: Might be too scary for some viewers


Overall, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark is a solid addition to the horror movie genre. It has impressive practical effects and CGI that bring its monsters to life, and a well-rounded tone that balances scares with humor and heart. However, if you’re someone who scares easily, you might want to watch this one with the lights on.